Accomplish More.
Juggle Less.
Everything you need to transform your work.

How to Switch Payroll Companies Without Disrupting Your Business

Payroll is a critical function for any business. It's responsible for ensuring that employees are paid correctly and on time and that all payroll taxes are filed and paid in full. If your current payroll provider is not meeting your needs, it may be time to switch.

Choosing the right payroll option for your business is important because it can save you time, money, and hassle. Outsourcing your payroll to a professional service can give you peace of mind knowing that your payroll is being handled correctly. 

Payroll services are experts in payroll processing and stay up-to-date on the latest tax laws and regulations. When choosing a payroll service, it is important to consider the cost, features and customer support. 

There are many different payroll services available, so it is important to do your research and find the one that is right for your business


Is It Hard to Switch Payroll Companies?

Switching payroll companies can be a daunting task, but it doesn't have to be. You can make the switch even smoother by choosing a payroll company that offers a free trial or demo, asking your new payroll company for help with the transition, and being patient. 

By following a few simple steps, you can make the transition as smooth as possible.


Reasons to Switch Payroll Providers

1. Inadequate Customer Service

When you are choosing a payroll provider, be sure to ask about their customer service policies. How long do they typically take to respond to customer inquiries? What is their policy on resolving customer issues?

You should also read online reviews of different payroll providers. This can give you an idea of what other customers have experienced with their customer service.

By taking the time to choose a payroll provider with excellent customer service, you can avoid the headaches and stress of dealing with a company that does not provide the level of support you need.

2. Limited Service Offerings

A good payroll provider should be able to meet all of your payroll needs, including:

    • Direct deposit
    • Payroll taxes
    • Time tracking
    • Employee benefits
    • HR support

Limited service payroll providers may not be the best option for businesses with complex payroll needs. They may not offer all of the features and services that businesses need, and they may not be able to provide the level of support that businesses need.

If you are considering using a limited-service payroll provider, be sure to compare their features and services to your needs.

3. Excessive Fees

Maybe your current payroll provider is expensive. Maybe the customer service leaves you wanting more. Or maybe the product isn’t easy to use or can’t meet your exact needs. There are many payroll providers that offer competitive rates.

4. Inaccurate Payroll Processing

Inaccurate payroll processing can have a number of negative consequences for businesses, including:

    • Employee dissatisfaction: Employees who are underpaid or overpaid may become disgruntled and less productive.
    • Government penalties: Businesses that fail to withhold taxes and contributions accurately may be subject to penalties from the government.
    • Legal liability: Businesses that make errors in payroll processing may be held liable for legal damages.
    • Damage to the business's reputation: Business that make errors in payroll processing may damage their reputation with employees, customers, and suppliers.

5. Lack of Compliance Expertise

A good payroll provider should have a team of experts who can help you stay compliant.

Compliance expertise is essential for businesses to avoid the negative consequences of non-compliance, such as fines, penalties, damage to reputation, and increased legal liability. 

Businesses can avoid these problems by hiring a qualified payroll provider, developing and implementing a comprehensive compliance program, and training employees on compliance procedures.

6. Outdated Technology

Up-to-date payroll technology can help businesses to improve efficiency, productivity, security, and compliance. 

Businesses should regularly review their technology needs and invest in new technology when it is needed to improve their payroll processes. By using up-to-date payroll technology, businesses can save time and money, reduce their risk of errors, and improve their overall compliance with government regulations.


Switching Payroll Companies Checklist

Review Your Current Contract

Before you switch payroll providers, be sure to review your current contract. This will help you determine how much notice you need to give your current provider and whether there are any early termination fees.

Research New Providers

Once you've reviewed your contract, it's time to start researching new providers. There are many payroll providers available, so it's important to compare their features and pricing before making a decision.

Ask for References and Check Reviews

After you've narrowed down your list of providers, be sure to ask for references and check reviews. This will help you get a better idea of what it's like to work with each provider.

Evaluate Compatibility with Your Business

Not all payroll providers are created equal. It's important to choose a provider that is compatible with your business size, industry, and needs.

Notify Your Current Provider and Employees

As soon as you've made a decision, be sure to notify your current provider and employees of the switch. This will help ensure that there are no disruptions in payroll processing.

Transfer Employee and Payroll Data

When you've notified your current provider and employees, it's time to transfer your employee and payroll data to your new provider. This can be a complex process, so it's important to work with your new provider to ensure that it's done correctly.

Set Up New Payroll System and Confirm Accuracy

It's time to set up your new payroll system. Be sure to test the system thoroughly to make sure that it's working correctly.

Train Employees on New Payroll System

After your new payroll system is set up, it's important to train your employees on how to use it. This will help ensure that they are able to submit timesheets and view their paystubs correctly.

Monitor Performance and Address Any Issues

As soon as your payroll system is up and running, it's important to monitor its performance and address any issues that arise. This will help ensure that your payroll is processed accurately and on time.


Switching payroll companies can be a daunting task, but it doesn't have to be. By following the steps outlined in this blog post, you can make the transition as smooth as possible.

And if you need a payroll service, let us introduce you to your best option: BELAY’s full-service managed payroll. 

Our managed, full-service payroll combines a simple implementation process, all the benefits of ADP, the nation’s most trusted payroll provider, and the high-touch service the great leaders we serve know to expect from BELAY.

It’s a modern payroll platform powered by humans. And where once you had to be an existing Accounting Services client, our Payroll offering is now available as an add-on service for all clients.

Stop stressing about payroll and start setting your organization up for success.

A growing organization means a more complex payroll. And now the option you chose to save money can quickly turn into costing you time and money. Here are 5 signs that it's time for you to outsource your payroll processing.