Skip to main content

How do experienced leaders deal with imposter syndrome?

Tricia Sciortino - CEO  

Executive Summary

Imposter syndrome hits capable leaders hardest. Learn why the doubt never fully fades and how to stop letting it make your decisions for you.

Imposter syndrome hits the most capable leaders hardest because it feeds on high standards.
The goal is not to silence the doubt. It is to stop letting it vote on your decisions.
A 2024 Korn Ferry study found 71% of U.S. CEOs experience imposter syndrome.
The doubt does not disappear with the next title. It showed up again when the author became CEO.
Feeling not enough is not evidence that you are not enough. It shows you take the work seriously.
Stop waiting for certainty before you lead. Certainty is not coming.
Build a body of evidence against the doubt: one decision, one room, one yes at a time.
The action comes first and the doubt quiets after. You lead your way out of it.

Imposter Syndrome Is Lying to You

The short answer

You don't wait for the voice to go quiet. You stop letting it vote. Imposter syndrome tends to hit the most capable leaders hardest, because it feeds on high standards. The way through is to build a body of evidence against it: one decision, one room, one yes before you feel ready at a time. I went from BELAY's first assistant to its CEO, and the doubt showed up at every step. What changed was my relationship to it.

The yes I said before I was ready

When Bryan asked me to take on more at BELAY, I was not ready. I had not done it at that scale. The voice had a lot of opinions. I said yes anyway.

When I stepped into the CEO role, it showed up again. Same fear, bigger title.

What changed was not the voice. What changed was my relationship to it.

Why imposter syndrome hits capable leaders hardest

The most capable leaders I know still wrestle with imposter syndrome. Not the ones who are figuring it out. The ones who have already built something real, led through hard seasons, and earned every seat they are sitting in.

That used to confuse me. Now it makes complete sense.

Imposter syndrome does not target the people who should not be in the room. It targets the people who care the most about doing it well.

A 2024 Korn Ferry study found that 71% of U.S. CEOs experience imposter syndrome. And 85% of those same CEOs say they are fully competent in the role. The majority of the people running companies in this country are privately questioning whether they belong there. Not early in their careers. Now. At the top.

78% of business leaders have experienced imposter syndrome at some point in their careers, and it does not ease up as you climb. It follows you.

Harvard Business Review has called high performers with imposter syndrome "insecure overachievers" and flagged them as a hidden burnout risk inside high-performance cultures. The doubt does not stay quiet. When you keep obeying it, it compounds.

You are asking hard questions. Holding a high standard. Paying attention to the gap between where you are and where you want to be. And then you take all of that and let it talk you out of the very things you are most qualified to do.

That is the lie. Imposter syndrome takes your strengths, your standards, your drive, and reframes them as evidence that you are not enough. It is not wisdom. It is fear with a very convincing argument.

4 ways to lead through imposter syndrome

1. Expect it to show up at every level

The doubt does not disappear with the next title. It showed up when I took on more at BELAY, and again when I became CEO.

Takeaway: If it's showing up, you're probably stretching, which is where growth happens.

2. Stop letting the voice vote

The goal is not to silence the voice. I have never met a leader who fully silenced it. I have met plenty who learned to stop letting it vote.

Takeaway: You can hear the doubt and still make the call.

3. Read the feeling for what it is

The feeling of not being enough is not evidence that you are not enough. It is evidence that you take the work seriously. Those are not the same thing.

Takeaway: Doubt measures how much you care, not how capable you are.

4. Build a body of evidence against it

Stop waiting for certainty before you lead. Certainty is not coming. The only way through imposter syndrome is to build a body of evidence against it. One decision at a time. One room at a time. One yes before you feel ready at a time.

Takeaway: You cannot think your way out of it. You have to lead your way out of it.

How to put this into practice this week

Every time you wait for the doubt to disappear before you act, you give it more authority than it deserves. The doubt does not go away first. The action comes first. The doubt quiets after.

1. Write down one decision you have been sitting on because you do not feel ready. Not because you lack information or the timing is wrong. Because the voice said wait.

2. Ask yourself one question: what would I do if I trusted my own track record as much as I trust the fear?

3. Make that move.

4. Write down what happened. That note is the first entry in your body of evidence.

The voice will still be there. Lead anyway.

What is one decision the voice has been talking you out of?

Frequently asked questions

Is it normal for CEOs to have imposter syndrome?

Yes. A 2024 Korn Ferry study found that 71% of U.S. CEOs experience it, even though 85% of them say they are fully competent in the role.

Does imposter syndrome go away as you get more successful?

Usually not. It tends to follow leaders as they climb, because it feeds on high standards. What changes is how much authority you give it.

How do you stop imposter syndrome from holding you back?

Stop waiting for certainty before you act. Pick one decision you've been delaying, ask what you'd do if you trusted your track record as much as the fear, and make the move.

---

Get The Limitless Leader in your inbox

If this was useful, you'll want the next one. Every other Tuesday, I send The Limitless Leader, a short email for leaders who are carrying a lot and want to grow without burning out. It's where pieces like this one start. Subscribe to The Limitless Leader